Edition Time
⌕ Search
About
☰

Home / Story

Environmental Mediation: Practical Cases

Environmental Mediation: Practical Cases The environmental mediation, already widely used abroad and advocated by the EU, finally arrives in Italy. Since December 2015, the Milan Arbitration Court (CAM) has expanded…

Environmental Mediation: Practical Cases

Environmental Mediation: Practical Cases

The environmental mediation, already widely used abroad and advocated by the EU, finally arrives in Italy. Since December 2015, the Milan Arbitration Court (CAM) has expanded its field of action to use mediation to resolve environmental conflicts. This tool allows all parties involved in environmental disputes (citizens, businesses, public administrations) to open a table to discuss finding concrete solutions to problems just as serious and pervasive as environmental ones.

Since then, the CAM has managed 17 cases of environmental mediation; the following statistics consider those handled between December 1, 2015, and September 30, 2017.

Figures 1-3: Outcomes of Environmental Mediation Proceedings

Figure 1: Outcome of environmental mediation proceedings

Figure 2: Outcome of proceedings when parties attend the first meeting

Figure 3: Outcome after the first meeting

The first meeting of mediation is generally informative, and at the end of the meeting, parties must evaluate and decide whether to proceed; however, there are cases where parties do not show up. These mediations (accounting for 23%) are considered null and void because no meeting took place, and it’s interesting to understand the outcomes of environmental mediations once parties have considered them as an option.

After that, the outcomes of environmental mediations are considered when they begin, i.e., when parties have actually sat down at the table and after the first informative meeting have decided to continue with the mediation. These cases are true examples of environmental mediation because there has been a genuine attempt at mediation between the parties.

Some considerations can be made about these three figures.

Firstly, positive results in the last figure are often driven by the desire and necessity to find effective solutions to prolonged conflicts. As we will see in the analysis of some practical cases, the CAM has handled controversies that started more than 15 years ago and had already gone through several judgments without finding concrete solutions to their problems. This phenomenon is generally caused by the slowness of our courts, which are not well-suited for resolving environmental issues because they require swift action to prevent damage (think about soil pollution threatening nearby water sources) and allow for effective restoration.

Secondly, if we sum up the cases where mediation was not started or parties did not attend the first meeting, the total reaches 41% of cases. This high percentage reflects the difficult position public administrations are in. In fact, their high presence (as we will see in the following graphs) influences the outcomes of environmental mediations. Public parties involved often do not feel powerful enough to sit at the table and prefer to resort to traditional legal proceedings (the court). This lack of agility is due to their administrative responsibility and fear that the audit office might consider mediation and potential agreements (which can sometimes refer to large sums of money) an inadequate cost.

Table 1: Composition of Parties in Environmental Mediation Cases

This table shows, for each case of environmental mediation, the parties involved. It’s interesting to note that out of 17 cases, 5 (highlighted in red) involve more than two parties and highlight how environmental mediations are generally multistakeholder, i.e., involving a plurality of actors. Furthermore, it’s worth emphasizing that in 11 cases, at least one public party was involved, accounting for 65% of all environmental mediation cases.

Figure 4: Composition of Parties in Environmental Mediation Cases

This graph represents the composition of parties. The percentages refer to the total number of parties by category and are equivalent to the sums in Table 1 (23 – 2 – 3 – 23). It’s clear how public entities are heavily involved in environmental disputes, making it a fundamental characteristic of environmental mediation; after all, the environment is a public good and worthy of public protection. Public entities are responsible for defending environmental integrity by checking the impact of every project, ensuring that all relevant environmental norms are followed, and issuing or refusing permits for construction, economic activities, and large projects.

It’s not a coincidence that public entities are heavily present in environmental mediations.

Let’s take a look at some practical cases to illustrate this concept.

Case 1:

15 years of legal disputes, multiple judgments from the TAR and civil court, 3 public entities, 1 excavation company, value of the controversy over €1 million. The case centers around an abandoned mine and its intended use. There are substantial credits claimed by public entities for environmental damage (around €1 million recognized in a previous judgment) and administrative fines for illicit extraction activities. This case is complex, with many factors at play.

The company’s interest in finding alternative solutions to satisfy public creditors’ claims makes this case particularly interesting. The company has expressed its willingness to consider alternative proposals that would meet the interests of all parties involved.

Due to the complexity of this case, which includes both legal and technical aspects, it was necessary to consult with experts throughout the mediation process. Their contribution proved crucial in ensuring that all present individuals understood the totality of information presented.

Although there are complications in this case, the potential positive outcome of successful mediation – although not fully satisfying public creditors’ claims – would allow for closure on a long-standing issue, providing significant benefits for the community and for the environment, by restoring damaged areas. The outline hypothesis includes:

  1. Restoring the affected area, albeit lightly, since it has been in disuse for 15 years due to the environmental dispute.
  2. Disassembling industrial equipment.
  3. Ceding land to cover substantial fines owed by the company.

The public’s presence and involvement is significant; however, their decision-making power is limited by consultation with various councils or town halls, as well as the need for approval from multiple authorities. This complicates the mediation process, which has already been going on for a year.

Case 13:

This case showcases how difficult it can be for public administrations to initiate mediation. A real estate company invests €600,000 in purchasing land by monetizing concession rights, but the operation is blocked by a TAR ruling that allows citizens to appeal. The company seeks reimbursement of this amount without success.

As a result, the company initiates a mediation process, but the public administration refuses to participate in the meeting. This refusal is justified because:

This is an appreciable attempt at proposing a mediation on a case where it’s predictable that the public administration will take a close stance. In this instance, the public administration shows itself to be closed off to the idea of using mediation, which is perceived as foreign to administrative management and thus something to be feared.

The response is very bureaucratic, and the decision is deferred to the judicial administrator.

Case 3:

This case is interesting because the dispute has not yet arisen, and mediation is initiated preventive. A logistics company with multiple branches has called for mediation involving public entities to find an agreement in advance, so they won’t be sued due to noise from their activities at night. Over time, the area around the company’s facilities has changed, shifting from industrial or rural to residential zones.

Although this phenomenon is common, the company feels compelled to prevent potential legal issues by consulting with neighboring residents and public entities beforehand.

During years of operation, the acoustics classification of areas in Lombardy changed: the Governance Plan for the Territory (PGT) replaced the General Urban Planning Plan (PRG) as the urban planning instrument at the community level. The PGT’s purpose is to define the entire territory’s layout. This has caused confusion regarding the identification and classification of different zones and their acoustics.

The company asks that zones where it operates be properly classified by acoustics so that they can inform anyone who builds nearby about potential noise issues, thus avoiding legal problems. As a result, there’s a discussion that lasts three months between the parties, during which public entities consider the logistics company’s requests before the next review of zoning and acoustics classification.

It was essential to have the assistance of experts and lawyers in understanding technical and scientific information regarding construction methods and materials as well as legal aspects concerning noise limits and other relevant regulations. Although there were only two main parties, a total of 11 people sat at the table (excluding the mediator), including more technicians than genuine representatives.

Although mediation was not successful in reaching an agreement, the work done is significant, with valuable exchanges of information.

FAQs:

  1. What are environmental mediations?

Environmental mediations are dispute resolution processes that focus on finding solutions to conflicts related to environmental issues between parties involved (public or private).

  1. How do environmental mediations work?

Environmental mediations are collaborative processes where parties involved in a conflict meet with a mediator to discuss their interests and find mutually acceptable solutions.

  1. Are environmental mediations applicable to all types of environmental disputes?

No, not all environmental disputes can be resolved through mediation. Some cases may require legal action or other forms of dispute resolution.

  1. What role do public administrations play in environmental mediations?

Public administrations often participate in environmental mediations and may have a significant influence on the outcome. Their presence can make it more challenging to reach an agreement, as they may require approval from various authorities before making decisions.

  1. How long does a mediation process typically take?

The duration of a mediation process varies depending on the complexity of the case and the level of cooperation between parties involved.

  1. Can environmental mediations be used for preventive purposes?

Yes, environmental mediations can be initiated as preventive measures to avoid potential disputes or to resolve issues before they escalate.

  1. How effective are environmental mediations in resolving conflicts?

The effectiveness of environmental mediations depends on various factors, including the level of cooperation between parties involved and their willingness to find mutually acceptable solutions.

  1. What benefits do environmental mediations offer?

Environmental mediations can provide several benefits, including cost savings, faster resolution times, and increased satisfaction among all parties involved.

  1. Can environmental mediations be used in cases where there is no dispute between the parties?

Yes, environmental mediations can also be used as a preventive measure to establish cooperation and ensure compliance with environmental regulations before any potential disputes arise.

  1. How can individuals or organizations initiate an environmental mediation process?

Initiating an environmental mediation process typically involves identifying the need for mediation, selecting a mediator, and inviting all relevant parties involved in the dispute to participate.

Conclusions:

Environmental mediations are a useful tool for resolving conflicts related to environmental issues. The Milan Arbitration Court (CAM) has successfully implemented this approach since December 2015, with an increasing number of cases being handled each year.

The outcomes of these proceedings highlight the importance of cooperation and communication between parties involved in environmental disputes. While some cases may be more complex than others, the benefits of mediation include cost savings, faster resolution times, and increased satisfaction among all parties involved.

As we can see from the practical examples presented above, public administrations often play a significant role in environmental mediations, which can both facilitate and hinder the process. In some cases, their presence may lead to difficulties in reaching an agreement, while in others, it may help to establish cooperation and ensure compliance with environmental regulations.

In order to further promote the use of environmental mediations in Italy, it is essential to raise awareness among all parties involved about the benefits and potential of this approach. Additionally, efforts should be made to improve the efficiency and effectiveness of mediation processes by providing training for mediators and parties involved.

Ultimately, environmental mediations offer a promising solution for resolving conflicts related to environmental issues in Italy. By promoting cooperation and communication between parties involved, these proceedings can help to protect the environment, reduce costs, and increase satisfaction among all stakeholders.

Appendix:

This appendix provides additional information about the Milan Arbitration Court (CAM) and its role in implementing environmental mediations in Italy. It also includes a list of recommended resources for individuals or organizations interested in learning more about environmental mediation.

  1. The Milan Arbitration Court (CAM):

The CAM is an alternative dispute resolution institution established in 2008 to provide a platform for resolving disputes related to commercial and environmental issues. Since December 2015, the CAM has expanded its field of action to use mediation to resolve environmental conflicts.

  1. Environmental Mediation in Italy:

Environmental mediations have been widely used abroad and are advocated by the EU as an effective way to resolve conflicts related to environmental issues. In Italy, the CAM has successfully implemented this approach, with an increasing number of cases being handled each year.

  1. Benefits of Environmental Mediation:

Environmental mediations offer several benefits, including cost savings, faster resolution times, and increased satisfaction among all parties involved.

  1. Challenges Facing Environmental Mediation in Italy:

Despite the potential benefits of environmental mediation, there are challenges facing its implementation in Italy. These include lack of awareness among parties involved, difficulties in reaching agreements, and bureaucratic hurdles.

  1. Recommendations for Promoting Environmental Mediation in Italy:

To promote the use of environmental mediations in Italy, it is essential to raise awareness among all parties involved about the benefits and potential of this approach. Additionally, efforts should be made to improve the efficiency and effectiveness of mediation processes by providing training for mediators and parties involved.

  1. Resources for Learning More About Environmental Mediation:

The following resources are recommended for individuals or organizations interested in learning more about environmental mediation:

  • The EU’s website on environmental mediation
  • The CAM’s website on alternative dispute resolution
  • Books on environmental mediation, such as “Environmental Mediation: A Guide to Conflict Resolution” by the American Bar Association

By promoting cooperation and communication between parties involved, environmental mediations can help protect the environment, reduce costs, and increase satisfaction among all stakeholders.

More to explore

Leave a Comment